Read also:
beko wmy7046lb2 7kg front load washing machine lg gb-310nwl review panasonic na-fs95g3wau review sunbeam torino coffee machine review rover ride on mower review masport 470 2 n1 lawnmowerThe Motley Fool (page 2 of 10)
Reviewer Photos & Videos
FlavBellbowrie
- 2 reviews
- 3 likes
Rubbish
I paid the 99$ (US) or so to sign up for a stock advisor thing, I had a very few e-mail about what I actually paid for.
But in return I get flooded with offer I don't even care about.... if I option out I wonder if I loose my stock advisor e mail that I actually paid for... so I don't
I don't even which e-mail is part of my subscription that I paid for.
All they want is selling you membership on top on another and another one....
Total waste of money!
Stay away and do some research, this what I do know.
1 comment
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Corrupt
Corrupt company. Trying to slug me $199 for something I never signed up to.
Prior to that I did pay a one year membership for about $90. Their stock tips were terrible. Disgusted by their corruption and incompetence. Total rip off. DO NOT go near them.
1 comment
Lianne E.The Motley Fool
Hi Nancy, thank you for your email, we're sorry to hear of your disappointment.
We do include automatic renewal as part of our sign up process however, this can be cancelled at any time during the... Read more
life of your subscription. We also send a renewal reminder 30 days prior the subscription expiry date.Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
GregSydney, NSW
A waste of time
I joined up hoping it was as good as promised but very disappointed and will not renew. Every day a new email with a teaser, with request to upgrade. It is clear the cheap "one year buy in" is to catch you for an upgrade later on. I receive far too many teasers and regard this site as unprofessional and focused solely on improving its own income. Marcus Today and Lincoln are far more professional.
1 comment
Lianne E.The Motley Fool
Hi Greg, thank you for your email, we're sorry to hear of your disappointment.
We offer our members different types of subscriptions depending on their individual investing needs. We have had many re... Read more
quests from members to specialise (eg small caps, resources, dividends etc) and by doing so we offer a 'pick and mix' service to allow our members the best options, based on their investing style.Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Paul KSydney, NSW
I’m a fool
I took out a subscription 1 year ago.I have bought shares on their recommendations and lost over 50% of my life savings.A very corrupt company with very little morals. You certainly made a fool out of me
1 comment
Lianne E.The Motley Fool
Hi there, Thank you for your email, we're sorry to hear of your disappointment.
We remain confident that our recommendations will prove to be quality ones, on average, in the fullness of time. Our ... Read more
experience to date shows that returns tend to be highly variable in the short term -- such is the nature of the sharemarket -- but that quality almost always wins out in the end.Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Don’t waste your time
One of the worst companies buyer beware.i really don’t know what there are doing.Some of the worst data and technical information. please be prepared for massive losses.So so terrible this is a scam.
1 comment
Lianne E.The Motley Fool
Hi there, Thank you for your email, we're sorry to hear of your disappointment.
We remain confident that our recommendations will prove to be quality ones, on average, in the fullness of time. Our ex... Read more
perience to date shows that returns tend to be highly variable in the short term -- such is the nature of the sharemarket -- but that quality almost always wins out in the end.Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Investing is hard, even with advice
I've been a MF Australia and US subscriber for 6 years now and can say I am pretty happy with what I've paid for. And I have paid quite a bit.
If you are to use a service like MF you need to understand a couple of things about how it works. Firstly, they cannot guarantee anything. Its in the nature of investing.
Second, they are a business, have costs and are looking to make a profit.
There are other things but these two are the main I think. They also stand at odds with each other because a business must promote itself to survive and be abl...Read more
e to provide a service. So the promotion side can look like you'll make a mint if you just buy the product. So my advice is: See the hype in their promotions and don't put too much significance to it.1 comment
Lianne E.The Motley Fool
Hi there, Thank you for your comments. Fool on!
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
shumbaSouth East Queensland, QLD
Rip Off
This company has to rate as one of the biggest rip offs. They don't do what they say they will do and their advice is very suspect. I believe any investment with them is a waste of time and money
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Avoid Avoid Avoid
I had subscribed to TMF a few months ago and closely watched the recommendations they provided. All stocks had large losses immediately after the recommendations. Constant spam emails to try and get more money from you with different memberships. Very little advice with even less value.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
AngelaPeel, WA
Bad Company. Don't deal with them
I joined Motley Fool Share Advisor last week, and despite repeated attempted to log in, they just won't accept my email address despite sending me at least two to three emails daily trying to flog other products. They have not returned any of my emails either. I can see from reviews that others have had the same problem. Don't fall for their palava. They are a scam company. I am going to contact my Bank and stop any further payments in the future to them.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Disapointing
I took 3 of its recommendation and they all turned out losses. The thing is that they managed to delete all big losers in score card, only keep gainers and small losers.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
daintree98
- 2 reviews
- 4 likes
Stock Gumshoe exposing the frauds
Check out stockgumshoe.com and the author Travis Johnson really drills down to expose the reality of these 'stock pickers'. Most of them are scammers who recommend buying stocks so they can 'short' and make a windfall at the expense of the mug fools. They never mention how many shares they own or their friends own in their 'stock pick' and if they are buyers or sellers.Basically they make money two ways, selling subscriptions and 'pumping and dumping' stock picks. Don't be caught with your pants down when the tide goes out.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Avoid recommendation
I took up a 12 month subscription to Dividend Investor and one of their first recommendations was RFG (Retail Food Group). Having known of an ex franchisee and their problems, I thought “no way !”. They continued to recommend RFG even as it was plummeting, and if you had taken their advice, you would be down 90% of your initial investment. I spent more time on their forum site comparing and discussing their dismal performance with other investors, than I did in taking their recommendations (thank goodness!).
Their head of Dividend Investor t...Read more
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Took my money, no membership activation, no response
Four days ago I warily paid for a 2 year membership and the money was deducted from my credit card. I was relieved to receive an email welcoming me to The Motley Fool group. HOWEVER, despite trying to log in for FOUR days, I receive a default saying that it doesn't recognise my email address. I being emailing them for four days requesting assistance but NO RESPONSE. I am now wondering to call my bank advising them that I have been scammed???
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
guydebylPerth, WA
- 2 reviews
- 9 likes
I love reading the recommendations.
I have made sold profits by following up on the recommendations and making a final decision myself. One must understand that not all recommendations will turn out profitable. Investors need to regularly monitor what they have decided on. I allow up to a 30% setback and concentrate on the recommendations that have had prolonged periods of upward movement. eg. CSL, ALU, ALL, A2M, MGX, ...etc.. all recommended by Motley's. I concentrate on several of their advisors. Funnily enough, I'm not a subscriber. Motley's are very generous in providing free information. Very happy.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Provides some of the worst share advice you can find
To get a feel for how bad this service is, all you have to do is look at the Motley fool's ASX share recommendations over the last 5 years and compare them to ASX market. They have a terrible track record. Worst subscription I ever purchased.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Extreme Oportunities NOT
I wish I had read reviews before joining their Extreme Opportunity subscription, received absolutely nothing for it and now am worried that come renewal they will automatically take from my account.
Im lodging a complaint with fair trading as no answers to emails and no number to call.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
FoolNoMoreMetropolitan Adelaide, SA
Not good!
TMF Australia has a lot of problems. The first is the free site and the click-bait articles, which are usually written by freelancers who are not full-time employees of TMF. The authors of those articles are paid for each article that is published and they often contradict the positions held by the full-timers at TMF (The Motley Fool). The click-bait articles always have a catchy headline like "Why XYZ went up 25% yesterday" or "Jeff Bezos says Amazon will go bust one day" and then a short story based on a few facts and then the "hook", such...Read more
as "click here for our free report on the 3 best dividend stocks you've never heard of". So many variations on the same theme. Even the full-time employees at TMF don't always agree - some services will say sell RFG and another service will still have them as a hold or even a buy. The worst thing about them is the constant cross-selling, trying to get you to sign up for more and more services - additional subscriptions, and they all come with auto-renewal - which you have to apply to have turned off - via email is best, or using the "contact us" link from any of their home pages. The forums are full of bullying and completely inappropriate language, stories, jokes, profanity, schoolboy humour at its worst, and I have rarely seen any moderation or intervention - usually only if there is a sustained attack on a TMF staff member. The DI service in particular was very disappointing. Very easy to lose money following their recommendations unfortunately. Often the only value to be found is in the better parts of the forums where some of the more experienced subscribers (who are not paid by TMF) offer some very useful advice at times. But even that is probably not worth the emails and constant pressure to sign up for more and more services and give them more and more money.Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
dodgy service!!!!!
This is a real waste of money. It is just an upsetting assault of automated emails trying to you to buy something else better spend $ elsewhere like Morningstar or a REAL financial service provider. The customer service is terrible as you can't speak with a person EVER just automated bots. Once your money leaves your cc its is damn near impossible to get it back so go directly to the cc provider and dispute the charge as emails are never replied to and the ph numbers are bot duds where no one ever replies. beware
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
- Verified customer
"Dividend Investor" is a bit dodgy
In their marketing for DI, Motley Fool only talks about their wins, not their losses . I paid a $99 1 year subscription to find out more, but after I signed on & read the Recommendation History covering over 2 years, I saw that the vast majority of the Recommendations lost a lot of money ( usually 10-50%) and also substantially underperformed the ASX benchmark . I promptly requested a refund & suggest others do likewise . I think I'm better off selecting stocks with the dartboard method.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Kerryn
- 7 reviews
Beware Beware!
This has to be some sort of scam. The shares we bought in 2016 on their advice eg.Telstra, have almost halved in price. Greencross have sold without any correspondence to us the shareholder at a 25% loss for us. G8 also recommended have showed consistent losses. I could go on and on. In our experience these are incompetent advisors in Australian shares. They sign you up for annual subscription at an inflated price from you're original commitment unbeknownst to you. I was reviewing my Paypal account and saw the ongoing payments which I cancelled immediately. Steer clear. Do not waste your time or money.
Similar opinion? Write a review on ieatwords.com.au!
Questions & Answers
HGR M.asked
Hi,
Very disappointed to read the negative views in this forum. 1.9 is really an absurdly bad rating! I use the MF in the US and would have liked to sign up for services on the ASX, but not after reading the reviews. I agree with the comments on the massive bombardment of unwanted extra services (mutiple times a day) You may want to consider softening some of your aggressive behaviour and repairing your poor customer service in a world where independent reviews are your potential new customers number #1 source for sorting the facts out. Till next year, Rob
3 answers
Erin B.The Motley Fool
G'day Rob.
We agree. We don't think 1.9 is even close to reasonable, given we're soundly beating the benchmark with almost all of our services. Our best guess is that this site might attract an unusually large proportion of disaffected current- and former-members, who have an axe to grind, or who have bought only a small portion of our recommendations and lost money.
Given some of our services cost less than a cup of coffee a week, and most are soundly beating the market, we're not sure that 1.9 reasonably represents either the quality or value for money of our services. Now, of course, anyone is allowed to post a review here, and we're at the mercy of those opinions to some degree. We hope readers will make their own judgements about services that are mostly benchmark-beating and are (we think) exceptional value for money.
You are, of course, welcome to your view on our marketing approach. You might even be right. On the flip-side, we have many thousands of customers who belong to our services. It might be a case of horses for courses. In a perfect world, we'd love to be able to say 'join a market-beating service for less than $200 for 12 months' and have people beat down our door (we note some fund managers charge more than 1% of assets for middling to sub-par performance), but we're competing for our potential members' attention. Now, that's our problem, not yours, of course, but we wanted to explain why we've found our strategy to be the most effective one of all that we've tried (thus far).
Thanks for taking the time to provide your thoughts, we appreciate it.
Thanks Erin for your excellent reply. I understand agree with you on most points. There are many platform tools available that would allow existing customers to select the amount of advertising they receive. Based on you reply I am going to reseach your offerings and give one a try this week. Thanks again, Rob
Erin B.The Motley Fool
That's great Rob - I'm pleased I was able to assist. If you have any questions with our products please contact the team at [email protected].
Geraldasked
When is the next discount on the premium service?
Ta
2 answers
Quite frankly I have no idea or interest!
Lianne E.The Motley Fool
Hi Gerald, Please email our Member Service team at [email protected] and they will be able to confirm service price options. We look forward to hearing from you.
Jeff Masked
Hi I want my subscription cancelled motley fool won’t answer any of my emails
4 answers
Hi Jeff, I had no problem in contacting Motley Fool and they cancelled my account and credited the amount charged, they contacted me within the hour, perhaps you could try calling them (07) 5564 5529 or check yellow pages for Motley Fool Brisbane, just google, good luck.
Thank you, I will call them tomorrow
Lianne E.The Motley Fool
Hi Jeff, Thank you for your note. Please email our Member Service department at [email protected] where they will be happy to assist with your subscription cancellation. Alternatively, please call 61 3 8592 4841. We look forward to hearing from you.
ieatwords.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ieatwords.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.
Lianne E.The Motley Fool
Hi there, thank you for your email, we're sorry to hear of your disappointment. We'd of course like to resolve this matter for you. Please contact our Member Support team at [email protected] and they will be able to assist further.